Skip to content
Micah Bornfree, PhDFormerly Micah WhiteFairfield, Iowa
Activist theorist; Co-originator of Occupy Wall Street; author of The End of Protest; advisor on the future of social movements.

Micah
Bornfree

I co-created Occupy Wall Street. It was a constructive failure. Now I’m asking: what is the future of protest?

The Globe and MailOctober 23, 2026Read at the GlobeUnabridged on Substack

I helped create Occupy Wall Street. Here’s what I’ve learned about why protests fail

Indignez-vous! Fifteen years ago, Occupy Wall Street, the Arab Spring and the indignados of Europe detonated a generation’s apathetic irony with an earnest cry for systemic change. Now, the world is watching a new visceral movement emerge from the grassroots to shake awake the status quo, this time out of France, one of the most historically significant countries for revolutionary politics – the French Revolution in 1789, the Paris Commune in 1871, Mai 1968.

There is a familiar pattern to these events, too: First the students, and then the many. More than 500,000 turned out last weekend in protests. But the demonstrations tipped from discontent into insurrectionary urges, arson at the 143-year-old Limoges Town Hall, looting in Paris and Marseille.

The history of social movements shows that these eruptions are contagious; the fever might just as suddenly appear in Canada. But the signs of dissipation are already visible. Three weeks ago the students had one clear demand, for teachers and classrooms; today, the movement has absorbed a whole set of frustrations around the cost of living, and the aims are muddled in the public’s eyes. With the world shocked at the damage done, the government has imposed strict curfews, insisted the movement has been hijacked, and is waiting for the fire to burn itself out.

The question is whether the provocation of the minority will sabotage the goals of the majority – a question I’ve been considering ever since Occupy Wall Street rose and ultimately failed to live up to its full potential in 2011.

In Occupy’s case, the dilemma playing out now in France manifested as the split between the insurrectionary impulse of Oakland and the prefigurative vibe of New York. One coast wanted a riot, the other a utopia. The ultra-leftists on the West Coast wrested control of the movement’s narrative just long enough to push through the alienating May Day General Strike. It was Occupy’s final act, and a failure.

So why do we, activists and authorities alike, keep repeating this scene? Until we figure that out, these flashes will continue to be squandered.

In the first 10 years after Occupy, I fervently believed that if activists were to update their model of protest, then the next movement wouldn’t repeat our mistakes. I wrote a book and gave lectures. But as the collective memory of Occupy began to fade, I was approached by one section of society that still cared to study the movement: elites. I ambivalently accepted invitations to speak first at the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development in Paris and then the World Economic Forum in Davos. Through those experiences, I realized I had misdiagnosed the problem as internal to movements, and so I ceased all public communication for the next six years: I quit social media; I studied in quiet; I changed my name; I moved to rural Iowa.

The conclusion I had come to was one that neither activists nor society were ready to hear: Activists need elites, and elites need protest.

If we strip away the political content of protest movements and look at them as a social phenomenon, something remarkable becomes apparent: In spite of repression, and with little to no funds as well as minimal planning, activists are able to manifest hundreds of thousands of people who break their normal routines, risking their physical safety. In these moments, human society opens itself up to the possibility of transformation.

When I watch the fires burn in Limoges, I don’t blame outside agitators or political extremists. You can’t have a movement without the full cast of players; trying to remove them is just the flip side of the political purity test. Instead, I’m reminded of the 25-year period after the first petroleum wells were drilled by Edwin Drake in 1859. Petroleum was used to make lamp oil, and gasoline, a byproduct, was considered worthless and dumped into rivers or burned – until Gottlieb Daimler, Wilhelm Maybach and Karl Benz pioneered the gasoline engine in the mid-1880s, turning the waste product into the vital force of modern civilization. Gasoline couldn’t create the engine; the engine can’t create gasoline.

Society’s understanding of protest is stuck in the lamp-oil era. What is most valuable is treated as a nuisance. Leon Trotsky saw the problem in 1930, when he wrote: “Without a guiding organization, the energy of the masses would dissipate like steam not enclosed in a piston-box. But nevertheless what moves things is not the piston or the box, but the steam.” For Trotsky, the engine was the Bolshevik Party. Nearly a century later, we can see the flaw in his steam-age piston-box: a political party cannot harness the full spectrum of the people’s fuel. The engine must run on revolutionaries, reformists and everyone in between.

What might this look like? Consider the secessio plebis: in 494 BC everyday Romans camped on the Sacred Mount, and elites, unable to run the city without them, brought them back not with coercion but by granting a new form of power – an assembly for the common people within the Roman state, and tribunes the elites could not touch, armed with a veto. The people could not have built it; the elites could not govern without it. It gave their civilization another thousand years.

Today’s political and tech elites have failed to do what activists cannot: build the engine that converts the unrefined manifestation of the many into a force for social transformation. At the same time, activists have failed to work with the engine-builders to shape what gets built.

I understand the activist refusal. I shared it for a decade. The fear is co-optation: being used, rather than being useful. But gasoline that refuses every engine is a fire that burns itself out. We have been discarding – through repression and the class-war mindset – what may be the most vital social force humanity has ever discovered.

Every protest that flares up is an opportunity; every protest that flares out is a tragedy. Our societies face many hard problems, some so ingrained, interconnected and vast that they can only conceivably be solved through the voluntary, unpaid action of millions of everyday people working collectively in new ways.

So to the political elite who control the police: Do not discard the fuel. Accept the risk of getting burned. To the technological elite with resources that activists lack: Build the engine. Scale co-ordination. And to the activists: The fuel is yours. Demand an engine.